Ontario court rules province must review 2,600 skilled worker immigration applications
A court ruled the province cannot retroactively return applications without a decision after citing fraud concerns.
TORONTO · An Ontario court has ruled the provincial government must individually review thousands of skilled worker immigration applications it had rejected or returned over concerns about fraud. The decision by two judges of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice affects roughly 2,600 foreign workers who applied for permanent residency through the Ontario Immigrant Nominee Program. The court found the Ministry of Labour, Immigration, Training and Skills Development did not have the authority to return completed applications without rendering a decision under the rules in place when the applications were submitted. The ruling states the applicants were entitled to a final decision on their completed files.
Around 300 of the affected workers were part of a court challenge against the ministry, fighting to have their applications assessed individually. In a majority decision released Monday night, two judges sided with the applicants, while a third dissented. The ruling orders the applications be sent back to the program director to be determined under the process that existed before a regulatory change in June 2025. That change allowed the ministry to return applications without a decision due to systemic concerns about fraud. "At the time they applied to the program, the Director had no authority to return complete applications without rendering a decision," the ruling states. "Under the relevant regulation, after determining that an application to the program was complete, the Director had an obligation to decide whether to grant it." The applicants argued the new regulation did not override their statutory right to receive a decision on their completed applications.
"I would allow the applications for judicial review and remit the applicants’ applications to the Director to be determined in accordance with the process in place prior to the regulatory change," the ruling adds.
Andres Pelenur, managing partner at Borders Law Firm and counsel for three of the applicants, said the decision confirms the province cannot arbitrarily change the rules for applicants who met all the program's demands. "Our clients worked a full year in a skilled trade in Ontario, were invited to apply under the OINP program, and were told their applications were complete," Pelenur said. "At that point the law entitled them to a final decision on their applications, and the OINP’s decision to retroactively cancel the entire stream constituted a clear breach of established law set down by the Supreme Court of Canada." Pelenur noted the court's order applies directly to the applicants before it, but its reasoning speaks to every individual in the pool of 2,600 affected persons. "We are pleased with the court’s well-reasoned majority decision," he added. Immigration consultant Kanwar Sierah celebrated the decision, calling it a landmark case in Ontario's immigration history. According to the ministry website, the Ontario Immigrant Nominee Program nominates people for permanent residence who have the skills and experience the Ontario economy needs, and the federal government makes the final decision to approve applications.
With files from CityNews