Navdeep Bains wins Ontario Liberal leadership by narrow margin
The former federal cabinet minister defeated MPP Lee Fairclough by less than one percentage point after a third ballot.
TORONTO · Navdeep Bains is the new leader of the Ontario Liberal Party after a narrow victory over MPP Lee Fairclough. The former federal cabinet minister won the leadership on Saturday, receiving 50.3 per cent of the vote on the third and final ballot. Fairclough, the MPP for Etobicoke, Lakeshore, finished with 49.7 per cent. The results were announced at the Metro Toronto Convention Centre after nearly two weeks of ranked-ballot voting by party members.
Bains addressed a crowd of more than 1,000 Liberals after his victory. He said the end of the leadership race marked the beginning of the campaign to replace Premier Doug Ford and the Progressive Conservatives. He accused the Ford government of failing Ontarians and described it as corrupt. "People want trust in government, and Doug Ford has lost that trust, and we’re going to work very hard to earn it," Bains said.
The close margin of victory raised immediate questions about potential divisions within the party. Bains said that would not be the case, noting that Fairclough told him "you have my full support" after the results. "We’re all united, and that’s what’s exciting because we all ran a positive campaign," Bains said. Liberal campaign strategist Blue Knox said the campaign was very collegial and doubted there would be unity questions. "I genuinely believe that Liberals are going to walk away from this ready to come together to get behind the new leader and win the next election," Knox said.
READ MORE: Ontario Liberals to name new leader in tight race between Bains and Fairclough
READ MORE: Ford government appoints eight regional chairs, including MP and former Liberal leader
However, a senior Ontario Liberal who supported Fairclough and asked not to be identified told iPolitics the final result was the "worst possible outcome" for Bains. The source said many in the party are concerned his victory represents a takeover by federal Liberals. The federal and provincial Liberal parties are not formally affiliated, but several federal Liberals were spotted at the event on Saturday. NDP strategist Erin Morrison criticized the leadership campaign, saying the candidates spent much of it talking about fixing the party rather than provincial issues. "All four leader showcases today... were not about policy. They were not about their plans for Ontario," Morrison said.
Bains now inherits a party with 14 MPPs and official party status, but one that remains well behind Ford’s Progressive Conservatives after three consecutive PC majority governments. He is the third consecutive Liberal leader without a seat in the legislature, following Steven Del Duca and Bonnie Crombie. Bains suggested he will seek a seat but did not commit to running in the next byelection or specify a riding. "I'll definitely be running, and the determination around the exact location will be made at the appropriate time," he told reporters. He said he would not ask a current MPP to resign to make room for him.
Progressive Conservative cabinet minister Graham McGregor, an observer at the event, congratulated Bains but previewed a likely line of attack from the government. "Certainly, in my region in Peel, we remember well when he was one of the biggest supporters of Justin Trudeau," McGregor said. Premier Doug Ford congratulated Bains in a social media post, saying Ontario families are counting on parties to work collaboratively. "I look forward to continuing that work," Ford said.
Bains is a former five-term MP who represented Mississauga ridings and served as federal minister of innovation, science and industry from 2015 to 2021. He left politics in 2021 and worked as an executive at CIBC and Rogers Communications. In his victory speech, he spoke about his parents immigrating to Ontario 50 years ago and said opportunities are now shrinking. "One in four people in my community of Mississauga visit the food bank, who have a job, who have multiple jobs, who play by the rules and are falling further and further behind," Bains said. He pledged to reverse recent changes to the Ontario Student Assistance Program, saying, "We’re going to reverse OSAP, ASAP."
Bains is the first racialized leader of the Ontario Liberals. When asked about the significance, he said it is important that people across the province feel they belong. "Doesn’t matter where you live, where you come from, you want to make sure you have a chance to succeed," he said. The other candidates in the race were Don Valley West MPP Stephanie Bowman and political strategist Dylan Marando. In a speech before the results, Bowman urged unity. "We came into this room as four teams. We must leave as one," she said. Interim Liberal leader John Fraser, who took on the role after Crombie's resignation in January, said ahead of the results he was excited and relieved to pass the baton. "It's a new beginning," Fraser said. "It's like a blank canvas."
With files from The Canadian Press, iPolitics and CBC News