Alberta premier defends high school changes as critics warn of lower standards
The changes, to be phased in starting in 2028, are opposed by teachers and the NDP, who say they lower academic standards.
Alberta Premier Danielle Smith has defended upcoming changes to high school graduation requirements, saying they are meant to give students more options and create pathways into skilled trades. The changes will see students earn more of their required 100 credits from optional courses like physical education, wellness and financial literacy. Smith said the province's education system has focused too heavily on preparing students for university. "We need to make sure that they have some meaningful career and profession to go to when they graduate," Smith said on her weekend radio show. The premier added she is tired of hearing the average age for starting an apprenticeship is 27, which she said means it takes people 10 years to find their calling.
The Alberta Teachers' Association, the Alberta NDP and some skilled trades workers oppose the changes. NDP Leader Naheed Nenshi said the government did not consult trades workers or their unions before introducing the plan. "They didn't talk to any skilled tradespeople or any of their unions to ask what the requirements needed to be and if this would help," Nenshi said. He argued the changes could lower academic standards and make it harder for students to get good jobs as workplaces are shaped by automation and artificial intelligence. "These changes make it harder for every single student to graduate and get a good job because they are based on the idea that students should do less rather than students should do more," Nenshi said.
Several skilled tradespeople joined the NDP at a news conference Friday to criticize the plan. Carpenter apprentice Paige Petraschuk said she likely would have taken less math in high school if given the option, but that would have made her apprenticeship training harder. "I've seen how much math and problem-solving are involved in apprenticeship training. I've seen classmates struggle because they didn't have the same foundation coming in," Petraschuk said. Scott Papineau, apprentice co-ordinator for Ironworkers Local 720, said trades are often wrongly seen as an alternative to academics. "That's not how today's trades work. Skilled trades rely heavily on math, science, and English," Papineau said. "Tradespeople use those skills every day to read blueprints, understand technical information, perform calculations, solve problems, and work safely."
READ MORE: Alberta to reduce high school core credits, boost options starting in 2028
READ MORE: Alberta premier says amendments coming to bike lane bill after backlash
Other industry representatives say they are hopeful the new flexibility will attract more future workers. "It would be great if so, because I mean there's a lot of significant workforce challenges happening in Alberta and across Canada," said Lisa Watson, executive director of the Mechanical Contractors Association of Alberta. Robin Bobocel, executive director of the Electrical Contractors Association of Alberta, also welcomed the changes. "We welcome any changes to the education system that enables more students to choose the trades, not just the electrical industry, but all trades," Bobocel said. He said the electrical industry currently has two apprentices for every journeyperson, and it takes four years to become a journeyman, so boosting numbers is not a quick fix.
The province announced last week that under the new requirements, students will only need to complete two humanities classes in their last two years of high school and can take one math or sciences course at the Grade 11 level. Nosy Mag reported in November that the changes will give students more flexibility to pursue trades and other interests. Students can still take a full academic course load if they choose. "What we are aiming to do with the changes that we’ve made is free up elective time in the schedule so that more kids can get the training that they need so that they can seamlessly enter into the skilled trades," Smith said in the legislature Tuesday.
BuildForce Canada says there could be a national labour force shortage of about 30,000 workers in non-residential construction by 2035. Watson said her industry now focuses recruitment efforts on junior high or even elementary school students, as many high school students have already made up their minds. She said there is a misconception about trades work. "The average student might be like 'I don't want to be a plumber, I don't want to deal with toilets overflowing my whole career.' There's so much more in the trades," Watson said. Bobocel emphasized the enduring demand for skilled trades. "It is an AI-proof job and it is a job for the future. You can't build data centres without electricians," he said. The new graduation requirements will begin to be implemented for Grade 10 students in the fall of 2028 and are expected to apply to all senior high school students by 2030.
With files from The Canadian Press, CityNews and CBC News