Nosy Mag
Supreme Court to rule on Quebec secularism law next week
Photo: Napoleon Sarony / Wikimedia Commons (Public domain)
Crime & Justice

Supreme Court to rule on Quebec secularism law next week

The landmark decision on the law that bans religious symbols for public servants will be released on Friday morning.

PA

OTTAWA · The Supreme Court of Canada will deliver its landmark ruling on Quebec's Bill 21 secularism law on Friday, Nov. 27. The country's top court announced the decision will be issued at 9:45 a.m. Ottawa time. The ruling is one of the most important Charter of Rights and Freedoms decisions in the court's recent history and addresses foundational questions about the Constitution. The judgment will be a reckoning with the political compromises of the early 1980s that led to the patriation of the Constitution and the inclusion of the Charter.

At issue is the 2019 Quebec law that prohibits many public-sector workers, including teachers and police officers, from wearing religious symbols such as a hijab or a cross on the job. The provincial government shielded Bill 21 from court challenges by invoking Section 33 of the Charter, the notwithstanding clause, which allows legislatures to override many Charter rights. Quebec's goal is secularism, but critics argue the law violates freedom of religion and targets minorities. The notwithstanding clause requires renewal every five years, and Quebec renewed it in 2024.

The case intensified federal-provincial political fissures, with the federal Liberal government arguing in March that the court should impose additional limits on the notwithstanding clause. Ottawa asserted that the clause's extended use to override rights effectively eliminates rights and rewrites the Constitution. Quebec insisted its political autonomy is in peril and argued against six groups of appellants who want Bill 21 struck down. "It is not up to the court to answer a political question that does not concern the courts," Quebec government lawyer Isabelle Brunet argued at the Supreme Court in March.

READ MORE: Supreme Court of Canada aims to rule on Quebec secularism law before retired justice's deadline

READ MORE: B.C. court quashes mine's 'substantially started' status, orders new consultation

Several provinces took sides in the case. Ontario, Alberta and Saskatchewan, all conservative led, sided with Quebec. The NDP governments in B.C. and Manitoba were open to a legal concept called judicial declarations but did not support limits on the notwithstanding clause. The federal government and some appellants want the court to endorse judicial declarations, where a superior trial court could rule that a law protected by the notwithstanding clause violates Charter rights, even as that law is allowed to stand.

Quebec's Bill 21 was twice upheld by lower courts in the province, in 2021 and 2024, both times because of the notwithstanding clause. In 2021, a Quebec Superior Court judge described the law as violating the basic rights of religious minorities but said the violations were permissible due to the clause. That ruling also created an exemption for English schools, which was later quashed by the Court of Appeal in 2024. Since Bill 21's adoption, Quebec has extended the ban on religious symbols to include support staff in schools and daycare workers.

The Supreme Court heard the appeal over four days in March, one of the longest hearings in the court's history. Seven judges of the top court heard the case. Justice Mahmud Jamal recused himself in July 2024 because he previously presided over the Canadian Civil Liberties Association when it decided to challenge Bill 21. To prevent a potential four-to-four split decision, Alberta Justice Mary Moreau was excluded from the bench. Nosy Mag reported earlier this month that Chief Justice Richard Wagner said the court aimed to publish the ruling before the end of retired justice Sheilah Martin's tenure. She retired in May but has until the end of November to participate in judgments.

The ruling comes at a politically sensitive time in Quebec, where the sovereignist Parti Québécois recently formed a minority government. Premier Paul St-Pierre Plamondon has said he would oppose any Supreme Court decision that invalidated key elements of Bill 21. The PQ has also vowed to ban children from wearing religious symbols in schools. The federal government has never invoked the notwithstanding clause, through decades of both Liberal and Conservative governments in power.

With files from The Globe and Mail and CBC News