Nosy Mag
Communities

Alberta premier says amendments coming to bike lane bill after backlash

Premier Danielle Smith says her government will propose changes to legislation giving it power to order bike lane removals.

HM

CALGARY · Alberta Premier Danielle Smith says her government is planning to amend its proposed legislation that would give the province power to order the removal of municipal bike lanes. Smith made the announcement on her Saturday radio show, two days after Transportation Minister Devin Dreeshen tabled Bill 43, the Safe and Sensible Roads Act. The bill would grant the minister authority to order bike lane removals and prohibit new lanes that reduce road capacity without provincial approval. It also states municipalities would be responsible for the costs of any removals ordered by the province, a point that has drawn sharp criticism from civic leaders.

Calgary Mayor Jeromy Farkas said Friday the bill appeared to be a "premature draft version." He said Smith's office had promised him the province would cover any removal costs. "My understanding and speaking with the premier's office is that was a mistake. The provincial government will fully pay for any change orders that are required," Farkas said. "The premier's office has told me that under no circumstances will municipalities be paying for this and I take that to the bank." Smith said Saturday her chief of staff met with Farkas this week and acknowledged the mayor had legitimate concerns. "We've got some amendments to propose to that (legislation)," she said.

Smith did not specify what changes would be made, and Dreeshen's office did not provide details when asked Saturday. In a statement, Dreeshen said the bill is "about better collaboration with cities to ensure we're making responsible, evidence-based transportation decisions that protect road capacity and make sure transportation networks work for everyone." He said Thursday the legislation responds to concerns that some bike lanes reduce road capacity, increase congestion and can hinder emergency vehicles. Dreeshen said the goal is to coordinate removals with scheduled road maintenance to lower costs.

READ MORE: Alberta premier defends high school changes as critics warn of lower standards

READ MORE: Alberta to reduce high school core credits, boost options starting in 2028

Edmonton Mayor Andrew Knack has also criticized the bill, noting that removing bike lanes installed in the last decade could cost the city $150 million. He said the actions of Smith's United Conservative Party government contradict its promises. "Their words mean nothing to me anymore," Knack said. During her radio show, Smith fielded multiple questions from callers concerned about the legislation. One caller described the bill's language as "draconian" and questioned provincial oversight of local decisions. Smith responded that the intent is only to examine bike lanes that reduce space for vehicles or are underused.

"I think that we just wanna make sure that we're putting them in the right place, that it's not interfering unduly with regular commuter traffic," Smith said. "We hope we can work collaboratively to identify better ways of designing them for the future." The bill also grants the province expanded oversight of municipal light-rail transit projects, requiring provincial approval for new or expanded LRT plans. Smith defended this provision, saying the province needs greater involvement as a major funding partner, especially when project costs escalate. She also cited concerns about fare collection and passenger safety on LRT systems.

During a technical briefing for reporters on Thursday, provincial officials said the responsibility for paying for bike lane removal was not addressed in the bill. However, the published legislation explicitly states municipalities must pay. Smith said her government's intention is to work collaboratively with cities on transportation planning. "We want it to be collaborative," she said.

With files from The Canadian Press, CBC News and CityNews