Nosy Mag
Ontario Liberals to name new leader in tight race between Bains and Fairclough
Photo: Rauenstein / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)
Politics

Ontario Liberals to name new leader in tight race between Bains and Fairclough

The party will announce results from a ranked-ballot vote of its 55,000 members on Saturday afternoon.

ML

TORONTO · The Ontario Liberal Party will name its new leader on Saturday, with results from a ranked-ballot vote of its 55,000 members set to be revealed at an afternoon event in Toronto. The contest is seen as a tight race between former federal cabinet minister Navdeep Bains and first-term MPP Lee Fairclough, with no clear runaway winner emerging after months of campaigning. This marks the party's third leadership contest since its 2018 election defeat, as it seeks to rebuild and present a serious alternative to Premier Doug Ford's Progressive Conservatives. The other candidates are MPP Stephanie Bowman and former political staffer Dylan Marando.

Party insiders say the outcome is difficult to predict. "Nobody knows what the result is going to be," said long-time Liberal strategist Blue Knox. "I think that's really healthy for the party. That means there are some real choices in front of voters and the best campaign really is going to win. This wasn't a runaway for anyone." Former Liberal cabinet minister John Milloy, now director of the Centre for Public Ethics at Martin Luther University College, echoed that sentiment. "I don't think any of them are the runaway winner," he said. "I've actually seen a fair amount of caution amongst Liberals. They want to hear people out, they want to kick the tires."

Navdeep Bains, the former federal industry minister who left a senior role at Rogers Communications to enter the race in May, was initially perceived as the front-runner. His camp estimates he signed up about 80 per cent of the new members enrolled during the leadership race, and he is the top fundraiser, having collected about $900,000. Lee Fairclough, a former hospital executive and MPP for Etobicoke-Lakeshore, is viewed to have pushed her way into contention with strong organizing and fundraising, having raised about $700,000. She has visited all 124 ridings and earned an endorsement from former premier Kathleen Wynne.

READ MORE: Mike Morrice to learn if he has mandate as Green Party prepares to announce leader

READ MORE: Quebec Liberals name opposition officers ahead of swearing-in

The party is using a ranked-ballot system where each of Ontario's 124 ridings is worth 100 points, divided based on candidates' support. If no candidate secures more than 50 per cent support on the first ballot, the last-place candidate is eliminated and votes are redistributed until a winner emerges. "Crazy things happen on a ranked ballot," Knox said. "If the other candidates manage to garner second and third ballot support, you can never say with 100 per cent certainty if it's going to go to any one candidate."

Stephanie Bowman, a former bank executive and two-term MPP, has raised nearly $600,000, while Dylan Marando has raised more than $200,000. Bowman has argued that the next leader must have a seat in the legislature to effectively challenge Ford, a point also made by Fairclough. "Being a third place party for the last eight years, and having tried a leader without a seat twice, you know, it is important for us to not make that mistake again," Bowman said. Marando, 39, has focused on generational change. "I'm in, potentially, the deluded stage of the campaign, because I'm convinced I'm going to win," he said.

Bains said his goal is to win on the first ballot. "The goal is always to win on the first ballot. I mean that's how we started the campaign with that mindset, and that remains our focus," he said in an interview. Fairclough said she has asked supporters to rank her first or second. "I have asked to be first on the ballot, and if I am not first on your ballot, I would like to be second as well," she said. "I do feel strong support."

The leadership race has been described as low-key and cordial, with candidates largely agreeing on policy and focusing their criticisms on the Ford government. "I think everyone wants to be everyone else's second choice, if not the first choice," said Liberal strategist Charles Bird, a principal at Earnscliffe Strategies. "Attacking your fellow candidates really doesn't make a lot of sense mathematically." Bird said the campaign has fostered a healthy policy discussion on areas where the Ford government is perceived to be weak.

The Liberals have been in third place in the legislature since their 2018 defeat, which cost them official party status. Steven Del Duca led the party from 2020 until resigning after the 2022 election loss, and Bonnie Crombie led from late 2023 until resigning early this year after receiving 57 per cent support in a mandatory review. The party regained official party status under Crombie after the 2025 snap election. Nosy Mag reported in November that former Liberal leader Steven Del Duca was among eight regional chairs appointed by the Ford government. Premier Doug Ford told reporters this week he does not have a preferred pick among the Liberal contenders. "All of them would be a disaster for this province," he said. The vote results are expected to be announced late Saturday afternoon.

With files from The Canadian Press, Global News and CBC News