B.C. court quashes mine's 'substantially started' status, orders new consultation
The ruling sends the decision back to the province and requires 90 days' notice for the First Nation to submit arguments.
Explainer
A British Columbia Supreme Court judge has ordered that a decision labelling a northwestern B.C. mine as “substantially started” be sent back to the provincial government for a new consultation process. Justice Emily Burke quashed the 2024 determination for Seabridge Gold's KSM Project, a proposed copper, gold and silver mine 65 kilometres northwest of Stewart, B.C. The ruling requires the province to give the Tsetsaut Skii km Lax Ha Nation 90 days' notice to present written submissions on whether the project had substantially started. The judge also stated the province must undertake "deep consultation" with the First Nation, which has territory in the project area. Justice Burke originally ruled in June that the province had not satisfied its duty to consult with the Tsetsaut Skii km Lax Ha Nation regarding the substantial start decision. Both sides later returned to her courtroom asking for clarity on how to interpret that initial ruling. In her latest decision, she provided the specific direction that the determination be set aside and the consultation process restart. The substantial start designation is significant because it means a project has made enough progress to retain its environmental assessment certificate. The KSM Project is a proposed copper, gold and silver mine located 65 kilometres northwest of Stewart, B.C. The province's assessment officer ruled in 2024 that the project had substantially started, meaning it had made enough progress to retain its environmental approval. Seabridge Gold CEO Rudi Fronk said in a statement on Thursday that the mine's legal status has not changed and that the company is very confident it has more than met the requirements for the designation. He said they also have the full support and impact benefit agreements with the principal First Nations that “have recognized traditional territory and treaty rights,” in the area of the mine.
What are the First Nation's concerns?
Chief Darlene Simpson said in a separate statement that the Tsetsaut Skii km Lax Ha Nation is not against responsible resource development. The nation's primary concern is the project's planned tailings storage facility. Simpson described it as a 52-storey-deep, nine-kilometre-long “toxic waste dump that uses a wet tailings approach” that has been found unsafe elsewhere. "If the province grants the (substantial start determination) to this project, our nation will have to live with that looming disaster on our territory for hundreds of years, because that poison can’t be moved and is of great risk of breaching containment over time," she said. The nation also stated that following the initial court ruling in June, Seabridge issued a news release incorrectly announcing that the court found the substantial start determination reasonable. In its Thursday statement, the nation expressed hope that the latest decision would lead to serious engagement. "With yesterday’s court decision, we hope the province finally understands it has to engage seriously with our concerns about such momentous effects on our territory," says the statement issued Thursday.
READ MORE: Ontario court rules province must review 2,600 skilled worker immigration applications
READ MORE: Supreme Court of Canada aims to rule on Quebec secularism law before retired justice's deadline
How has the mining company responded?
Seabridge CEO Rudi Fronk emphasized the company's confidence in meeting the requirements for the substantial start designation. The company says it will be reaching out to the environmental assessment office to see when a new substantially started determination could be reached. It is encouraging the office “to conclude it promptly.” The court's order means the provincial assessment officer must now restart the process, providing the 90-day notice period for the Tsetsaut Skii km Lax Ha Nation to make its case before a new decision is made.
What is the legal background of the case?
This legal dispute stems from the province's 2024 decision to grant the substantial start determination for the KSM Project. The Tsetsaut Skii km Lax Ha Nation challenged that decision, leading to Justice Burke's initial June ruling that consultation was inadequate. The return to court for clarity resulted in the specific orders issued in the latest decision. The process now returns to the provincial government's environmental assessment office to conduct the consultation as directed by the court.
With files from The Canadian Press, CityNews and Toronto Star