Nosy Mag
Mississauga data centre moratorium faces two tribunal appeals
Photo: CityLimitsJunction / Wikimedia Commons (CC0)
Canada & the World

Mississauga data centre moratorium faces two tribunal appeals

Prologis and Montcrest Asset Management are challenging the city's one-year pause on new projects at the Ontario Land Tribunal.

DC

MISSISSAUGA · Two companies are appealing Mississauga's one-year moratorium on new data centres at the Ontario Land Tribunal, setting up a legal test of municipal power to pause development. The U.S. real estate giant Prologis and Toronto-based Montcrest Asset Management have both filed notices of appeal against the interim control bylaw passed unanimously by city council in September. The bylaw blocks new data centres with energy demands above 10 megawatts, roughly enough electricity for 10,000 homes. Mississauga Mayor Alvin Tedjo said he is prepared to fight the challenges. "I say, bring it on," Tedjo told CBC News. "The residents of Mississauga have been crystal clear that they do not want to see the American real estate investment trusts come down and tell us what they want to build in our communities."

The moratorium, which can be extended for a second year, was framed by officials as a necessary window to study grid strain, noise and land-use impacts before drafting permanent rules. It froze a proposed 40-megawatt data centre project backed by Prologis in the city's Meadowvale business park along Highway 401. In a statement, Prologis said the moratorium was "poorly conceived, without justification for its restrictions or consideration of the consequences for businesses seeking to invest in Mississauga." A company spokesperson, Mattie Sorrentino, said the bylaw creates uncertainty and delays investment, arguing the city already has an established planning process to evaluate individual projects.

Montcrest Asset Management is challenging the decision for its Tahoe Centre property in northeast Mississauga, near Dixon Road and Eglinton Avenue. The company said it appealed to ensure "clear guidelines for future building in the community." In its submission to the tribunal, Montcrest argued the bylaw improperly regulates power use, which is a provincial responsibility, rather than land use, which is municipal. "An interim control by-law cannot be used to freeze land while a municipality studies matters that its zoning power cannot regulate at the end of the study," the company said. A spokesperson, Melissa Fernandez, said Montcrest recognizes data centres raise legitimate questions about infrastructure and environmental impacts and is committed to working within the regulatory regime.

READ MORE: North Atlantic right whale population declines again as U.S. weakens protections

READ MORE: U.S. sanctions eight Canadian firms for alleged Iran sanctions evasion

Mississauga is one of at least six Ontario municipalities to enact a similar pause in recent months, and the largest of that group. The surge in proposed data centre projects is driven by the artificial intelligence boom, with some proposals exceeding 100 megawatts in energy demand. Councillor Martin Reid, who championed the moratorium, said in a video posted to social media Tuesday that the fight is not done. He said development should never come before planning. Tedjo said the moratorium allows the city to determine conditions for data centres without runaway developments that consume lots of power and disrupt communities. "But right now, it's the wild west. None of those regulations exist," he said.

Premier Doug Ford has been critical of local restrictions, framing data centres as a promising investment. In August, his government introduced a new data centre framework that would base approvals on economic development, data protection and community investment. Several municipal leaders have said they have been left with little guidance or enforceable standards. Toronto Mayor Olivia Chow, who was re-elected last month, campaigned on a promise to bring in a moratorium on AI data centres. The legal challenges are at the intake stage at the Ontario Land Tribunal and await assignment to a case coordinator. No timeline has been established for a result.

Kyle Gossen, a partner at Davies Howe LLP who specializes in land use planning law, said interim control bylaws are rare because they prohibit development for up to two years. He said he would not be surprised if more municipalities pass similar bylaws and more companies appeal them as the issue becomes more common. Gossen added that case law from the tribunal will likely set a precedent for future cases. Ontario Green Party leader Mike Schreiner said the fight is worth the effort. "Our electricity rates are at risk, the health and safety of our communities are at risk, and the fact that Mississauga voters have said 'we want to control the future of development in our community, not U.S. tech billionaires,' that's worth fighting for," he said.

With files from The Canadian Press, The Globe and Mail and CBC News