Nosy Mag
Third offender in 2019 Calgary murder case pleads guilty to lesser charge
Photo: Robert Thivierge from Thunder Bay, Canada / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 2.0)
Crime & Justice

Third offender in 2019 Calgary murder case pleads guilty to lesser charge

Robert Daignault pleaded guilty to accessory after the fact, receiving a time-served sentence of three and a half years.

PA

CALGARY · A Calgary judge said there will be "no justice" for Kasif Hirani as the third and final person involved in his 2019 killing pleaded guilty to a reduced charge on Tuesday. Robert Daignault, originally charged with first-degree murder, pleaded guilty to accessory after the fact to murder. Court of King's Bench Justice Colin Feasby accepted a joint sentencing proposal for a three-and-a-half-year, time-served sentence, meaning Daignault will be released from custody. The judge said he was required to accept the recommendation but did not have to like it.

"Rarely do I, as a judge, have feelings of dissatisfaction," said Feasby. "Today is different." He noted that Hirani's death "was a murder," but none of the three participants were convicted of that offence. Feasby said the outcome was disappointing. "It is clear to me there is no justice for Kasif Hirani," the judge said.

Daignault was in the middle of his retrial on a manslaughter charge when he entered the guilty plea to the lesser charge. The plea came after shaky testimony from a co-accused, Trista Tinkler, who gave many "I don't remember" answers to prosecutors. The Crown and defence lawyers acknowledged the litigation risk of continuing the trial. Prosecutor Elisa Frank and defence lawyers Andrea Urquhart and Michelle Carrigan submitted a joint proposal for the sentence.

READ MORE: Second Nova Scotia minor hockey player pleads guilty to sexual assault charges

READ MORE: U.S. woman pleads not guilty to conspiring in Tumbler Ridge mass shooting

An agreed statement of facts filed in court says Daignault knew Hirani had been murdered and that his then romantic partner, Tinkler, was involved. In the days after the killing on Dec. 29, 2019, Daignault and Tinkler stole $14,000 from Hirani using his bank cards. Daignault then drove Tinkler to Edmonton on Dec. 31, 2019, with the intention of helping her evade arrest. The pair were arrested in Edmonton three days later.

Two others were previously convicted for their roles in the crime. Trista Tinkler pleaded guilty to manslaughter in 2022 and received a six-year sentence, which Feasby described as "relatively light." She has finished serving her sentence. Andrew Christal was convicted of manslaughter in 2023 and received an eight-year sentence, also described by the judge as relatively light. Christal is now out on parole. The testimony of Tinkler and Christal was described as "problematic" and uncorroborated, which led to Daignault's first manslaughter conviction being overturned by the Alberta Court of Appeal last year.

In a victim impact statement, Hirani's wife, Salmi Khetani, called him "my most favourite person on the planet." She wrote that she is "alone, lost and isolated." "I am in a dark tunnel where I don't see any light," said Khetani. The Supreme Court of Canada has set a high bar for judges to reject a joint sentence proposal, requiring them to accept it unless it would bring the administration of justice into disrepute or is contrary to the public interest.

With files from CBC News