Liberals limit debate on MAID bill as opposition MPs demand more study
The bill would allow advance requests for assisted dying and block its expansion for mental illness.
OTTAWA · The Liberal government has moved to restrict parliamentary discussion on its proposed changes to medical assistance in dying. MPs voted Monday to adopt a motion from Justice Minister Sean Fraser that limits second reading debate to one additional day. This decision came despite opposition calls for more time to examine the legislation. Bill C-41, tabled on Oct. 27, would amend the Criminal Code to permit advance requests for an assisted death and would halt a planned expansion of eligibility to individuals whose sole condition is a mental illness. The bill must pass both the House of Commons and the Senate before a March 17 deadline when the current law would otherwise allow that expansion.
Conservative MP Tamara Jansen condemned the government's action, calling it "absolutely shameful" for a matter of life and death. She accused the Liberals of withholding necessary information from parliamentarians. "The Liberals had all summer, and now it has been nearly three weeks since Bill C-41 was introduced. We still have not seen the government's own analysis of how this bill could affect Canadians' Charter rights, and yet they are already shutting down debate," Jansen said. The Conservatives support excluding mental illness as a sole basis for MAID but have urged the government to separate the bill to allow deeper scrutiny of advance requests.
Bloc Québécois MP Martin Champoux expressed dismay at what he described as the government muzzling the House on a sensitive issue. "I am at a loss for words to describe how I feel about the government employing this manoeuvre, especially on such a sensitive topic," said Champoux. He acknowledged the government's desire to proceed quickly and avoid Conservative filibustering but insisted a broader public conversation was needed. Fraser responded that MPs have had "ample opportunity" for debate both in Parliament and through committee studies, and he said discussion would continue when the bill reaches committee.
READ MORE: Federal government tables bill to exclude mental illness from MAID eligibility
READ MORE: Pamela Wallin resigns from Senate, cites assisted dying policy as closure
The government has delayed several times the date when mental illness alone could qualify someone for an assisted death. A special parliamentary committee recommended in June that such access be barred indefinitely. Under existing law, MAID is available to adults with a grievous and irremediable physical medical condition who are in an advanced state of decline and can give informed consent at the time of the procedure. The new provision for advance requests would apply to people with degenerative diseases like dementia, allowing them to consent in advance to a death after they lose capacity.
Fraser noted the pressing legislative timeline, with the March 17 deadline looming. "It is also not lost on me that we are dealing with a set of circumstances in which if we do not adopt this law expeditiously, we are going to come up against a mandated timeline," he said. The government stated that any request for MAID must be voluntary and protected by rigorous safeguards. The federal bill would enable advance requests but leaves it to provinces to decide whether to implement them through their health systems.
Quebec is currently the only province with a framework for advance requests, while Alberta has legislated against them. Fraser told reporters he was somewhat concerned about creating a patchwork of rules across the country but said he would be "more concerned about extending access without the safeguards in place." Federal safeguards include requiring two independent medical or nurse practitioners to confirm a person meets the criteria. The legislation also specifies that the procedure must not proceed if the person demonstrates any refusal or resistance at the time it is to be administered.
Fraser said he aims to see the bill pass the House before the current sitting ends in December. This would give the Senate sufficient time to consider and pass the law before the March deadline. The ongoing debate over assisted dying has drawn significant commentary from senators. Nosy Mag reported in October that former senator Pamela Wallin cited the assisted dying policy as a reason for her resignation.
With files from The Canadian Press, CBC News and CityNews