Nosy Mag
Carney says Canada's China trade not top U.S. concern after meeting Trump at APEC
Photo: World Economic Forum from Cologny, Switzerland / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 2.0)
Canada & the World

Carney says Canada's China trade not top U.S. concern after meeting Trump at APEC

The prime minister said a deal with the U.S. is possible but complex, while announcing new tariff relief from Beijing.

DC

SHENZHEN · Prime Minister Mark Carney said U.S. President Donald Trump is not overly concerned with Canada's expanding trade ties with China. Carney made the remark Wednesday in Shenzhen, China, after a 20-minute meeting with Trump on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit. He said the president has sought to understand Canada's direction with China, but it is not a top issue for him. The leaders discussed ongoing efforts to reach a new trade agreement between their two countries.

Carney said he believes a mutually beneficial deal with the United States is still possible. He described the negotiations as making progress, albeit with some setbacks. A readout from the Prime Minister's Office said the potential agreement would create jobs, improve affordability and respect Canada's sovereignty. The prime minister stressed any final deal must be in the interest of Canadians. The comments follow criticism from White House trade adviser Peter Navarro, who accused Canada of trying to play China off against the U.S. Navarro wrote on social media that the tactic was offensive and warned China could "eat Canada alive." Carney has said talks with Washington remain his priority, but their outcome will influence whether Canada looks to other partners for auto industry investment. He has suggested European, Chinese or Japanese automakers could be alternatives.

Earlier in the week, Carney met with Chinese President Xi Jinping and secured new tariff concessions. China agreed to cut tariffs on approximately $400 million worth of Canadian exports, such as frozen pork, fish and seafood. Canada will reciprocate by extending tariff exemptions on some Chinese steel and aluminum products for two more years. This builds on a deal from January that paused Chinese tariffs on Canadian canola, peas, lobster and crab.

READ MORE: Carney secures Chinese tariff cuts while defending trade strategy

READ MORE: Carney to join APEC photo with Putin out of respect for Chinese host

Carney argued Canada's trade with China is fundamentally different from the U.S.-China relationship because it involves commodities, not advanced technology. "We are exporting canola, we are exporting pork. We are exporting halibut," he said, also mentioning liquefied natural gas and oil. He said these are important industries but not sensitive sectors like cutting-edge semiconductors. The prime minister said the renewed relationship also opens doors in financial services, clean energy and technology.

In an interview with the New York Times DealBook Summit, Carney said trade talks with the U.S. are far more complex than those with China. "Look, it should have been done six months ago, but, we're not going to sign something that doesn't make sense for Canada," he said. He pointed to recent trade deals with Southeast Asian nations and the Philippines, and an expected pact with India, as proof Canada is not waiting on the U.S. Nosy Mag reported earlier this month that the leaders had ordered a resumption of formal talks after they collapsed in August. Conservative international trade critic Stephanie Kusie said it is concerning to see the government engage with China given its human rights record. She accused Carney of using trade diversification as a distraction from his failure to secure a U.S. deal. Kusie said Canada's historical and geographical ties with the United States are far more significant and should be the focus, not a nation that does not promote democracy or the rule of law.

Carney defended discussing trade with China while also raising human rights and foreign interference concerns. He said the most effective approach is to have open, frank conversations with Chinese leaders. The prime minister explained Canada's trading relationships exist on a spectrum, with some partners allowing free trade and others, like Russia, receiving no trade at all. He added that renewed ties with Gulf states could help address conflicts in Gaza, Iran and Ukraine. Foreign Affairs Minister Anita Anand and Carney's chief of staff attended the meeting with Trump, along with several senior U.S. officials including Trade Representative Jamieson Greer and Secretary of State Marco Rubio. Canada's Trade Minister Dominic LeBlanc has not travelled to Washington for in-person talks since negotiations restarted, but senior government officials say there have been regular phone and video calls involving the chief trade negotiator.

With files from The Globe and Mail, CBC News and CityNews