Carney secures Chinese tariff cuts while defending trade strategy
The prime minister said his approach is pragmatic and not a top concern for President Trump, as critics warn of risks.
SHENZHEN · Prime Minister Mark Carney has secured additional Chinese tariff cuts on Canadian pork and seafood exports while extending Canadian tariff exemptions for certain Chinese steel and aluminum products. The agreement, announced during Carney's visit to Shenzhen for the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit, follows his meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping on Tuesday. The Prime Minister's Office said in a readout that Carney and Xi agreed to "further elevate this partnership" and that "the peoples of both countries are benefiting from these renewed ties." The deal provides immediate relief for Canadian sectors that have faced Chinese trade barriers.
China agreed to drop tariffs worth up to 25 per cent on about $400 million worth of Canadian pork and seafood shipments. It also extended a tariff pause secured in January for Canadian canola meal, peas, lobster and crab, and committed to take more lentils, fava beans, wild aquatic products and pet food. Kyle Larkin, president and CEO of the Canadian Meat Council, said pork producers have suffered under the Chinese restrictions and called the deal "a great step in the right direction." Statistics Canada data show Canadian trade with China hit a record $12.7 billion last quarter, with exports increasing by 60 per cent over the last two years.
In return, Canada will extend tariff exemptions for certain Chinese steel and aluminum products by two years and expand remission measures for products not available in sufficient quantities domestically. Blair Dickerson, president of the Canadian Steel Producers Association, said the changes are not expected to have much impact on the domestic industry. "If there's something that we can't make in this country, then we're OK with it," she said, adding the remissions could be rescinded if Canadian companies start making those products. Carney will also continue to allow tens of thousands of Chinese electric vehicles to enter Canada annually at a reduced tariff rate.
READ MORE: Carney says Canada's China trade not top U.S. concern after meeting Trump at APEC
READ MORE: Carney to join APEC photo with Putin out of respect for Chinese host
The prime minister defended the trade strategy during a news conference in Shenzhen on Wednesday, saying Canada's relationship with China is fundamentally different from the U.S.-China relationship. "We are exporting canola, we are exporting pork. We are exporting halibut," Carney said, also citing liquefied natural gas and oil. "These are important industries. These are not cutting-edge semiconductors." He said his approach is pragmatic and maintains "guardrails" to prevent the two countries from becoming too intertwined. Carney said he discussed the China relationship with U.S. President Donald Trump and that, in Trump's hierarchy of issues, "it's not the top issue at all."
Carney's comments came amid criticism from Trump trade adviser Peter Navarro, who accused Canada of threatening to "play China off the U.S." and wrote on social media that "China is going to eat Canada alive." The criticism follows strained Canada-U.S. ties after Washington imposed 50 per cent tariffs on about $20 billion in Canadian goods in August, prompting retaliation from Ottawa. Carney has said negotiations with the United States remain his priority, but their outcome could determine whether Canada pursues alternatives involving European, Chinese or Japanese automakers. Nosy Mag reported in November that Carney would meet with Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum at APEC to discuss shared challenges posed by U.S. tariffs.
Michael Kovrig, a former diplomat detained in China after the arrest of Huawei executive Meng Wanzhou, said he is watching the improving relations with "a great deal of concern." He urged Carney to tread carefully, noting China has weaponized tariffs in the past. "There are definitely some potential benefits. The challenge is to make sure that the benefits don't come with bigger and more problematic downsides," Kovrig said in an interview with CBC News. He said the readout from the Carney-Xi meeting did not mention national security, transnational repression or human rights issues. "They should also be a priority along with market access," he said.
Kovrig also warned that drawing closer to China and allowing new imports like electric vehicles and steel products has the potential to anger the Americans, jeopardizing Canada's most important economic relationship. "You have to put Washington first. I know that's not a popular idea in Canada right now," he said. Vina Nadjibulla, co-founder and CEO of the Centre for Strategic Statecraft, said U.S. trade actions necessitate Canada looking elsewhere for business. "China's behaviour hasn't changed, but Canada's strategic circumstance has," Nadjibulla said. "We are now living in a world in which we do have to diversify and we do have to economically engage with China in certain areas."
The agreement includes a vague commitment to "deepen co-operation" in finance. A government backgrounder states that, after past approvals for Chinese automaker BYD, a second company, Geely, has secured Transport Canada permissions to import its foreign-made cars. Carney said he plans to meet with Trump later Wednesday after the U.S. president arrives in Shenzhen, where they are expected to discuss bilateral trade. "We have been making progress," Carney said on getting a deal with the U.S., adding it must be "in the interest of Canadians."
With files from The Canadian Press, The Globe and Mail and CBC News