U.S., China, Russia pledge nuclear risk talks after historic trilateral summit
The leaders agreed to engage in dialogue to reduce nuclear risks and boost fuel supplies after a meeting in Shenzhen.
Analysis
The leaders of the United States, China and Russia met for a historic trilateral summit in Shenzhen on Thursday. U.S. President Donald Trump, Chinese leader Xi Jinping and Russia’s Vladimir Putin held talks for over an hour on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation forum. Following the meeting, Russian officials and Chinese state media announced the three nations had agreed to engage in dialogue to reduce nuclear risks. They also pledged United Nations reforms and to boost fuel supplies, though their joint declaration did not mention the wars in Ukraine or Iran.
Trump said the three men had “a special responsibility to maintain open, respectful and constructive dialogue.” He framed the gathering as a chance to establish rules for controlling nuclear arms and to begin resolving conflicts in Ukraine and Iran. Xi stated the discussions would focus on promoting world peace, and Chinese state broadcaster CCTV reported he called for prohibiting and destroying nuclear weapons. Putin invoked their shared history as victors in the Second World War, saying they held joint responsibility for maintaining international peace.
READ MORE: Anand points to travel advisories for China risk, cites arbitrary detention concerns
READ MORE: Carney says Canada's China trade not top U.S. concern after meeting Trump at APEC
The most concrete outcome appeared to be a tentative step back toward nuclear disarmament. The last arms control treaty between Russia and the U.S., called New START, expired in February. Trump has said he wants “a new, improved and modernized” deal that includes China. China has never agreed to limits on its arsenal, which contains over 600 warheads, a fraction of the more than 5,000 each believed to be held by the U.S. and Russia.
Experts warn against expecting major deals
Analysts cautioned that a single meeting was unlikely to yield significant agreements. Daryl Kimball, executive director of the Arms Control Association, said the summit could at best initiate a process leading to sustained talks on reducing arsenals. “We need more than diplomatic theater and photo opportunities between Xi, Putin, and Trump at APEC,” Kimball said. “And one meeting will not likely produce dramatic breakthroughs.” Trump himself acknowledged the challenge, telling Fox News before the meeting that “it’s a very hard thing to do” to ask a leader to reduce nuclear stockpiles.
The unprecedented three-way meeting drew comparisons to the 1945 Yalta Conference, where major powers divided post-war influence. The Kremlin dismissed the analogy as “games of political scientists,” but said the event would majorly impact global affairs. The Wall Street Journal editorialized that the summit was “creating more anxiety among allies than adversaries.” Some European and Asian capitals expressed unease, fearing the world’s top military powers might disregard smaller nations’ interests. Trump conducted the negotiations without involving Ukraine or traditional U.S. allies like Germany, France, Britain, Japan and South Korea. His approach evoked an era of great power politics where stronger nations decided the fates of others. The U.S. president has openly sought a Nobel Peace Prize while authorizing military actions against Venezuela and Iran earlier in his term.
Personal dynamics show geopolitical divides
Trump, who frequently offers of his personal rapport with world leaders, also held separate bilateral meetings. He met one-on-one with Putin for about 40 minutes, their first talks since failed negotiations on Ukraine in Alaska last year. “Wonderful things can come out of this, or at least start,” Trump said, calling Putin “my friend.” He also held a private session with Xi, their third substantial meeting this year, before the trilateral gathering.
Xi had greeted Trump on the airport tarmac on Wednesday, reciprocating a gesture from their last meeting and sharing a brief hug. Yet the public warmth between Trump and the two autocrats was not fully reciprocal. At the APEC summit, Xi called Putin “my old friend,” and the Russian leader declared Xi his “dear friend.” When Xi visited the White House in September, he was more reserved, saying only that he and Trump had built a “personal rapport and stayed in touch.” China has provided crucial economic support to Russia following its 2022 invasion of Ukraine, offering a financial lifeline amid Western sanctions. Xi told Putin their relations “have remained steadfast through storms” and brought “greater stability and certainty to a world marked by intertwined changes and turbulence.” Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said the two leaders discussed the Ukraine war and Trump’s envoys trying to end the conflict.
Frictions in the U.S.-China relationship surfaced despite the cordial summit. Chinese officials blocked a Bloomberg reporter from the trilateral meeting after she asked a question at the earlier Trump-Xi session. Chinese state television aired a clip showing Trump appearing drowsy, while the White House posted video of Trump helping Xi up an escalator. Tensions also persist over trade and artificial intelligence, including recent U.S. restrictions on advanced AI chips from companies like Nvidia.
In a speech at APEC on Wednesday, Xi positioned China as a champion of global trade, urging support for “free and open trade and investment.” He called for upholding the rules-based multilateral trading system with the World Trade Organization at its core. His remarks contrasted with U.S. policies under Trump, which have included tariffs and a more muscular foreign policy. George Chen, partner at The Asia Group, said Xi’s message “is likely to resonate with many Global South countries and reinforces Beijing's effort to contrast its technology strategy with that of Washington.”
Putin used his APEC address to criticize Western powers, calling them “former hegemons” and declaring Europe in a “humiliating decline.” He claimed sanctions imposed over the Ukraine war had backfired. “Experience has shown that the traditional tools of economic dominance and de facto coercion have largely run their course, having lost much of their intimidating power,” Putin said. He expressed hope for “big potential benefits from the upcoming trilateral meeting.” Trump and Xi are scheduled to meet again at the Group of 20 summit in Florida this December.
With files from The Globe and Mail, CBC News and CityNews