Thousands urge Ottawa to halt radio tower on bird migration hot spot Pelee Island
A Chicago trading firm's plan to build a 182-metre tower has sparked fears for migratory birds and a lack of transparency.
Thousands of birding advocates have sent messages asking the federal government to intervene in a U.S. company's plan to build a 182-metre radio tower on Pelee Island in southwestern Ontario. Conservation groups and residents warn the tower and its support cables would be a deadly obstacle for hundreds of thousands of birds that migrate over the island each spring and fall. The tower, slated for construction next year on township land leased by Chicago-based DRW Holdings, LLC, is intended to transmit stock trading data to the U.S. east coast via microwaves. The public comment period on the project expires on Monday. As of Sunday evening, a public awareness campaign had generated upwards of 26,000 letters calling for a federal environmental assessment, said Matthew Gibson, who is spearheading the effort for the Pelee Island Bird Observatory. "If you wanted to kill a lot of birds with a huge, deadly tower, a LOT of birds, you couldn’t have planned it better," wrote author Margaret Atwood, a part-time island resident who helped establish the observatory, in a Substack post alerting followers to the issue. Atwood invited people to fill out a digital letter to be sent to Environment Minister Julie Dabrusin, the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada, and Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada.
The island's township council approved the tower last year, but many property owners say they only became aware of the full scope of the project this summer. Some residents have expressed frustration over a lack of transparency and the fact no public meeting was held. "It’s preposterous and it’s appalling all at the same time," said Ron Tiessen, a 47-year island resident, who added the tower would be a "visual blemish" obvious from anywhere on the island. The details of the township's lease agreement with DRW, including the revenue amount, have not been made public. In an email to The Globe and Mail, Cathy Miller, who just completed her term as mayor, said council had met its obligations under federal rules and Ontario's Municipal Act. In an August email to the bird observatory's board chair, Deborah Egan, Miller wrote that the lease would raise significant revenue for township infrastructure, which she said would have been irresponsible to ignore. Miller helped arrange a meeting between DRW and observatory representatives, but Matthew Gibson said the discussion did not shed much more light on the project details.
Birds Canada, which also attended the meeting, expressed deep concern in a statement. "Birds Canada is very concerned that the tower will not be designed to eliminate impacts on birds and will become an ongoing source of mortality," said David Browne, the organization's senior vice-president for conservation and policy. The bird observatory's board is now pursuing a freedom of information request to learn the details of the township's arrangement with DRW. Dave DeLellis, the incoming mayor who was on council when it approved the tower, said the matter would be a "top priority" for the new council after it is sworn in on Tuesday.
Pelee Island, covering about 40 square kilometres, is home to Canada's southernmost community and is internationally renowned for birdwatching due to its position at the confluence of two major migration corridors. The Pelee Island Bird Observatory opened a new $3.5-million research facility in September, funded by Atwood and others. A letter from the township's property-owners' association notes the island's economy and real estate values depend heavily on nature-based tourism. The association also notes that an impact study commissioned by DRW does not assess bird collisions. In statements to media, DRW has said it is committed to mitigating the tower's impact on birds. The tower requires a licence from Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada to broadcast, which has not yet been granted. The Impact Assessment Agency of Canada has the jurisdiction to decide whether the project requires a federal environmental assessment before it can proceed.
With files from The Globe and Mail