Ontario man convicted of animal cruelty for stealing flamingo from Las Vegas hotel

Analysis

A Canadian man has been convicted of animal cruelty for stealing a flamingo from its habitat at a Las Vegas hotel. Mitchell Fairbarn, 34, from Ontario, was found guilty Monday on felony and misdemeanour charges for taking the bird named Peachy from the Flamingo Las Vegas Hotel and Casino on March 3. He faces up to four years in prison for the felony conviction and an additional six months for the misdemeanour. Fairbarn, who pleaded not guilty, remains under house arrest pending a sentencing hearing scheduled for December 1.

Prosecutors argued Fairbarn’s actions were malicious, while his defence lawyer said they were the result of drunken foolishness with no intent to harm. Surveillance video, photos and Snapchat clips shown at trial depicted Fairbarn grabbing the Chilean flamingo by the neck, smiling and laughing. Video evidence showed him carrying the bird through a hotel hallway and into an elevator. Las Vegas police said photographs and video from Fairbarn’s phone showed him aggressively choking the bird and throwing it to the floor.

READ MORE: U.S. woman pleads not guilty to conspiring in Tumbler Ridge mass shooting

READ MORE: Ottawa youth found guilty of terrorism charges in plot against Jewish community

"I thought it was something that we could joke about for the rest of our lives," Fairbarn said in court Friday, according to video footage of the trial. He testified that he had consumed between 30 and 40 beers over 24 hours while in Las Vegas for a construction expo. He described taking the flamingo as a drunken "silly pranky joke." Fairbarn denied any malicious intent to hurt or kill the bird. His lawyer, Joshua Tomsheck, told jurors his client deeply regretted his actions.

The bird's injuries and recovery

Peachy, a 27-year-old flamingo, was injured during the incident. The bird’s treating veterinarian, Tiffany Moore, testified that Peachy suffered seven to eight missing feathers, broken feather shafts and blood loss consistent with trauma. Moore said the bird needed antibiotics, anti-inflammatories and weeks of pain medication. A hotel facilities engineer who found Peachy told the court the bird was shaking and bleeding. Animal control officials testified that the flamingo suffered a wing injury that required stitches and that the wing had been pulled from its body.

A "large bloody feather" was later found in Fairbarn’s hotel room, according to investigators. Since the incident, a spokesperson for Caesars Entertainment said Peachy has recovered and is doing well physically. The spokesperson said the bird is now more anxious and nervous during evaluations. "We are grateful this matter was taken seriously and appreciate the work of law enforcement, prosecutors and the animal care professionals who responded," the spokesperson said.

Defence argues lack of intent

Fairbarn’s defence centred on his claimed lack of intent to cause harm, a key element for the felony charge. Tomsheck asked Fairbarn in court if he had any malicious intent "in your mind or your heart when you picked up that bird." Fairbarn shook his head and answered, "no." Tomsheck acknowledged his client’s poor judgement. "He should not have done that, should not have gone into the habitat, shouldn’t have touched a bird, shouldn’t have taken Peachy inside," Tomsheck said. "The truth is, Mitch was drunk. Mitch was stupid. He made bad decisions."

Fairbarn also testified about his experience with animals, saying he grew up on a farm, owns dogs and a parrot, and once rescued an abandoned llama and six ducks. He claimed he entered the habitat because he noticed the flamingo had uneven wings and thought something might be wrong. Prosecutors presented a different narrative, with evidence showing Fairbarn hopped a fence around 5 a.m. and took the bird. Two of Fairbarn’s friends testified they woke up in their hotel room to find the flamingo there before moving it to the hallway.

Personal consequences and broader context

Fairbarn spoke about the personal fallout from the incident, telling the court his family has faced break-ins, death threats and his children had to change schools. Clark County prosecutor Haley Willming acknowledged those events were unfortunate but noted "none of that would have happened had he not done what he did, had he not made the choices he made." Fairbarn had to surrender his passport as a bail condition and has been under house arrest in Nevada since March, unable to return to Canada when his father died during the trial. The case is one of several recent animal cruelty incidents at Las Vegas casinos. In June, a woman was charged after allegedly jumping into a fountain at The Venetian and grabbing a duckling. In May, a teen girl was arrested and accused of stabbing three horses at an equestrian centre. Outside the courtroom after the verdict, Nevada animal rights advocate John Waudby said he believes justice was delivered for Peachy. "I hope this sends a message to anybody else that wants to mess with our animals, that you're not going to do it in Nevada," Waudby said.

With files from National Post, CBC News and Global News